William Young and Associates Blog

DUI While Riding A Horse??? I Have So Many Questions...

Posted by William Young | Dec 29, 2017 | 0 Comments

Most of the time people are arrested for DUI during the operation of a car, truck, boat, motorcycle, or ATV. Every now and again you even hear stories of DUI while operating a bicycle. DUI on a horse was a new one for me... 

DUI On A Horse

53 year old, Donna Byrne of Lakeland, Florida was charged and arrested for drunk "driving" her horse. A driver sharing the highway with Ms. Byrne called 911 and reported that Ms. Byrne was riding her horse in the middle of the road and appeared confused. The caller was (understandably) worried for Ms. Byrne's safety. Officer's "pulled over" Ms. Byrne and recorded breath samples of .161 (over double the legal limit). https://www.nbcnews.com/news/weird-news/florida-woman-horseback-charged-dui-n817231

I am not sure what the law is on drinking a riding in Idaho (check back later, I will do some research) but I think it is fair to say that it is not a good idea even if it turns out not to qualify as a DUI. Is it really a DUI if you "vehicle" has a mind of its own and can operate without your input? I mean cattlemen used to fall asleep in the saddle all the time when driving a herd, does this qualify as reckless driving? What I am sure of is that, under Idaho law to be guilty of DUI you must be operating a vehicle on public roadways, does this mean that had she taken a shortcut through the swamp or ridden beside the road the DUI charge would have been dismissed? These are all interesting questions that I am sure I will never have reason to answer. If you have a horse DUI case PLEASE let me take it on, I would probable even be willing to do so Pro Bono just to satisfy my curiosity!

Also what do you do in this situation:

DUI On A Horse2

I feel like this guy had to be drink when he came up with this "vehicle" and we can't really say he is in the "driver's position" - he is on the hood of the car! Or the photo above with the dog...is the intoxicated man a passenger at this point? While it might be reckless to let your dog drive, I think he has beat the system as far as a DUI charge is concerned.

The question that really has my head spinning is what the charge would be if the horse was drunk but the rider was sober...some sort of equipment violation? Failure to maintain lane based upon the horses drunken wondering? I am taking suggestions!  

Well that is my random post for the week. Happy New Year! Stay safe out there!

About the Author

William Young

Idaho Criminal Defense and Trial Attorney. I was admitted to the Idaho State Bar in May, 2014, and for the next 4.5 years I practiced as part of Peterson Lawyers with the father-daughter tandem of Chuck Peterson and Courtney Peterson. They were great mentors to me and I still consider them among...

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Free Consultation

Each case is unique. The strength and weakness of your case will depend on the particular facts of your case. Contact us for a free consultation. We will answer any questions you have, and give you an honest assessment of your case.

Committed To Every Client

We are committed to providing every client with respect and compassion they deserve; Every case will receive our full attention and passion. We work one-on-one with every client to make sure you get the best defense possible.

950 W. Bannock St.
Suite 630

Boise, ID 83702
(208) 344-0128
Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu, Fri: 08:30am - 05:00pm

Copyright © 2020 William Young and Associates

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Every case is different, nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any specific case. Viewing the information contained on this site does not constitute an attorney-client relationship.

Menu